How to Plan Through Disruption When Supply Falls Over
Most planning processes are built for a world where next month looks roughly like last month. The forecast is a single number, the plan is reviewed weekly or monthly, and the main job is trimming error at the edges.
Then a fire goes through a growing region, a flood cuts the highway, a supplier's site gets locked down, or a biosecurity incident takes a chunk of your raw material out of the market overnight. Suddenly the forecast is meaningless, the plan is out of date by lunchtime, and everyone from the CEO to the key account managers wants to know what's going to happen.
In Australian food and FMCG, this is not a once-a-career event. If you plan for long enough, you will plan through several. The businesses that come out in decent shape rarely have the best forecast. They change how they plan, quickly, and stick to a few simple rules.
This is a practical playbook for doing that.
Why normal planning breaks in a disruption
Three things go wrong at once.
- The inputs stop being reliable. History is no help when the constraint is new. Supplier confirmations change daily. Demand swings because customers panic-buy, switch from a competitor who is also short, or stop ordering altogether.
- The cadence is too slow. A weekly plan in a situation that changes every day means you are always making decisions on stale information. By the time the S&OP meeting comes around, the decisions have already been made, badly, by whoever happened to pick up the phone.
- Nobody has agreed the rules. When there is not enough to go around, someone has to decide who gets what. If that hasn't been agreed upfront, it gets decided customer by customer, by whoever shouts loudest. That is how you end up shipping your best customer 60% and a marginal one 100%.
None of these are forecasting problems. They are process problems, which can be fixed in days.
1. Swap the point forecast for a range
In a disruption, a single number gives a false sense of precision and invites the wrong argument ("is it 4,200 or 4,600?"). What you need is a small set of scenarios that bracket what could plausibly happen, and a clear view of what you would do in each.
Three is usually enough:
| Scenario | What it assumes | What it is for |
|---|---|---|
| Bad | Supply recovers slowly, constraint lasts longer than people hope | Sizing the worst cash and service exposure, deciding what to protect |
| Expected | Your honest best guess, updated as information arrives | The plan you actually run day to day |
| Good | Supply comes back quickly, demand normalises | Making sure you don't over-commit to expensive workarounds you won't need |
Two rules make this work. First, each scenario is driven by a few explicit assumptions (supply volume by week, recovery date, demand uplift or drop), written down where everyone can see them. Second, when an assumption changes, you update it, not the output. That keeps the conversation on "do we still believe the supplier is back in week 6?" rather than relitigating every number.
The value isn't in predicting which scenario happens. It's in knowing what you would do in each, and which decisions are the same across all three (those you can make today).
2. Move to a daily cadence, and keep it short
When things are moving daily, the plan has to move daily. That does not mean a two-hour meeting every morning. It means a tight, repeatable 20 to 30 minutes with the people who can actually make decisions.
A workable daily agenda:
- What changed since yesterday (supply confirmations, inbound, production actuals, customer orders, anything from the field). Five minutes.
- Position by critical SKU: stock on hand, confirmed supply, committed demand, days of cover. Ten minutes, on one page.
- Decisions needed today: allocations, production changes, freight, customer messages. Ten minutes.
- Owners and next check-in. Two minutes.
Keep the attendee list small: planning, procurement, operations, a sales lead and someone who can approve spend. Bring finance in a couple of times a week, because disruption decisions get expensive quickly.
Decide upfront what triggers stepping back down to the normal cadence. "When confirmed supply covers expected demand for four consecutive weeks" is better than "when things settle down", which in practice means never, or far too early.
BUT don't get distracted by trying to make things perfect. During this period the most important thing in alignment. There were times during all critical moments that I've had the privilege of managing where data was not available or changing so far that it took longer to pull into a slide than just talk to it. Utilise your expert to talk openly about the challenges and their ideas on how to manage it. Then utilise discussion to gain alignment, not slides.
3. Agree the allocation rules before you need them
This is the single most valuable thing you can do, and it is best done in the first day or two, before the pressure from individual customers builds.
Allocation rules answer one question: when demand exceeds supply, who gets what, and why? The common approaches:
- Fair share. Everyone gets the same percentage of their normal order. Simple, defensible, easy to explain. The default if you have nothing else.
- Priority tiers. Some customers or channels are protected first (contracted volumes, essential services, a key retail partner), and the rest share what is left.
- Margin or strategic weighting. Protect the volume that matters most. Sensible, but harder to explain, and needs commercial sign-off.
Whichever you choose, base it on normal demand (for example, the average of the 8 to 13 weeks before the disruption), not on current orders. Current orders are inflated by customers who have worked out that ordering more gets them more.
A worked example
Here is a hypothetical case using illustrative numbers. Nerd Foods, our fictional 10-SKU manufacturer, has 6,000 cases of a key SKU available next week. Normal weekly demand is 10,000 cases across four customers. Customer A has a contracted minimum and is protected at 90% of normal.
| Customer | Normal weekly demand | Current orders | Rule | Allocation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A (contracted) | 3,000 | 4,500 | Protected at 90% of normal | 2,700 |
| B | 4,000 | 6,000 | Fair share of remainder | 1,886 |
| C | 2,000 | 2,000 | Fair share of remainder | 943 |
| D | 1,000 | 2,500 | Fair share of remainder | 471 |
| Total | 10,000 | 15,000 | 6,000 |
The arithmetic: after protecting A at 2,700, there are 3,300 cases left. The other three customers have 7,000 cases of normal demand between them, so each gets 3,300 / 7,000, or about 47%, of their normal volume.
Notice what happens if you allocate against current orders instead. Total orders are 15,000, so everyone gets 40% of what they ordered. Customer D, who more than doubled their order, gets 1,000 cases (their entire normal week) while the contracted customer is short. Allocating on current orders rewards exactly the behaviour that makes shortages worse.
Write the rule down, get sales and the GM to sign it off, and apply it consistently. Exceptions go through one named person, and get logged.
4. Talk to customers early, honestly and on a rhythm
Customers can usually cope with bad news. What they can't cope with is surprises, or a supplier who says "should be fine" on Monday and short-ships on Thursday.
A few principles:
- Tell them early. As soon as a constraint is real, even without all the answers.
- Give them the range, not just the number. "We expect to supply 45 to 55% of normal volume for the next three weeks, and we'll confirm each Friday" is far more useful than a single figure you'll have to walk back.
- Explain the rule. If every customer knows allocations are based on normal volume, the incentive to over-order largely goes away.
- Set a rhythm. A weekly update at a fixed time, even if it says "no change", builds more trust than ad-hoc calls when things get worse.
- One voice. Sales owns the conversation, planning owns the numbers, both from the same sheet.
5. Decide when to drop SKUs
When capacity or raw material is constrained, running the full range is often the worst option. Every changeover, every small batch and every low-volume pack size uses capacity and material that could go to the lines that matter.
A quick triage for each SKU, in a spreadsheet, in an afternoon:
- What share of volume and margin does it carry? Rank the range. In most FMCG businesses, a minority of SKUs carry most of the volume.
- Does it share constrained inputs with a bigger SKU? If two SKUs use the same scarce raw material or line, the smaller one is the obvious candidate to pause.
- Is there a substitute the customer will accept? A different pack size of the same product is often fine for a few weeks.
- Is there a contractual or ranging risk? Some SKUs need to stay on shelf to keep the listing. Know which ones before you pause them.
- How hard is it to restart? Packaging minimums and retailer data can make a "temporary" pause sticky.
Pausing 20 to 30% of the range for the duration of a constraint is not unusual, and it often lifts total output because the plant spends less time changing over. Be explicit that it's a pause with a review date, not a quiet delisting.
During the pandemic, there was the most profitable product sales wanted to sell, but the most efficient product that the factory could make ultimately meant more product out the door and overall more profit. Don't be afraid to discuss and decide on an uncomfortable position, provided the trade off is worth it.
6. Don't forget the recovery
The recovery is where a lot of damage is done. Customers all rebuild stock at once, so demand spikes just as supply returns, and three months later you're writing off short-dated excess.
Keep the allocation rules in place for a few weeks after supply returns, step order caps up gradually, and watch customer orders against their normal run rate. If you've read Why You're Out of Stock and Overstocked at the Same Time, the recovery from a disruption is where that pattern is born.
A one-page disruption checklist
- Three scenarios with written assumptions, owner and update date
- Daily 20 to 30 minute meeting with a fixed agenda and a small decision group
- Exit trigger for returning to normal cadence
- Allocation rule based on normal demand, signed off by sales and the GM
- One named approver for exceptions, with a log
- Customer update on a fixed weekly rhythm
- SKU triage list: protect, pause, substitute, with review dates
- Recovery plan: order caps, staged return to full range
What to do this week
You don't need a disruption to get ready for one. This week:
- Write a draft allocation rule. Which customers or channels would you protect, and on what basis? Get it in front of sales and the GM now, while nobody is under pressure.
- Calculate normal demand by customer for your top 20 SKUs. An 8 to 13 week average is fine. Store it somewhere you'll find it when you need it.
- Run the SKU triage on paper. If your biggest raw material halved tomorrow, which SKUs would you pause first?
- Agree who would be in the daily meeting. Five or six names, and who has authority to approve spend.
If you'd like an outside view of how ready your planning process is for the next disruption, that's one of the things a Planning Health Check looks at.
Member discussion